As this class has
continued on and we have progressed our way through the assigned readings, I
finally found a book I think I enjoyed. The Return of The Native by Thomas
Hardy was actually an okay book. I really do enjoy reading but I strongly
prefer to read books of my choosing and read on my time. This book was filled
with many twists and turns. The characters had quite the personalities. One character
in particular, Eustacia was one of my interest. She seemed so shallow and
selfish. She wanted so bad to leave the heath. She wanted to leave and be away
from the natives of Egdon Heath. At times though, this book was hard to follow
and understand but looking at a couple criticisms seemed to help and give me
some new insights into Hardy and the novel.
The first criticism was
by Donald Davidson. Davidson discussed an interesting point of view on the
novel. I first learned from him though that Hardy wrote ballads and it could be
possible that his ballads were turned into long works of fiction. Davidson also
discussed the point that Hardy wrote for particular reasons; “He sought to
please and entertain, and perhaps instruct…” (427). The part about Hardy
wanting to instruct makes sense since I feel that the point behind some of the
scenes in Return of the Native hold morals or truths that he is trying to tell
us through the characters and their narrative. Davidson’s main point in his
criticism really is that Hardy wrote outside of his time. He wrote in another century,
not from his own. He was more “advanced” than his fellow writers.
The second criticism was
by Gillian Beer. Beer made a good point that I guess I really didn’t think much
about until reading his criticism. He made the point that Clym was the native
that returned and he was significantly advanced compared to his peers and
neighbors that stayed their lives in the Heath. He ‘regressed back to savageness’
as Beer puts it. He brought back advanced ways of thinking, i.e the education
and the ways of teaching he wanted to do; the school he wanted to open. Hardy
may have done this on purpose to show us like Clym coming back to a lower
place, Hardy was writing outside his time period but by bringing Clym back, it
brought Hardy back to his real time period.
These criticisms helped
me to take a closer look at the characters and the Hardy himself.
*the criticism essays
were found in the back of the Return of the Native book that I own.